Casting follows source material and franchise lore without alterations: Robbie Kay portrays the traditional young male Peter Pan, new additions like Robin Hood, Tinker Bell, Ariel, and Zelena integrate organically into the story without clashing with setting or prioritizing representation. Female characters such as Emma, Regina, and Snow White are capable and central, but their strength derives directly from the show's established magical and narrative traditions rather than modern activist framing.

No race- or gender-swapping of established figures occurs, no explicit critiques of patriarchy or systemic issues appear as plot drivers, and LGBTQ+ elements are absent in this season. Minor background diversity exists through fantasy archetypes but remains incidental and does not influence arcs or themes.

Audience and critical reception focused on plot twists, character development, and entertainment value with no notable backlash over ideological messaging. The season adheres to traditional storytelling tropes of heroism, family bonds, and moral conflicts without embedding contemporary social justice activism.