Jenny (Katherine Heigl) proposes to her long-term partner Kitty (Alexis Bledel) after years of concealment, then compels her conservative Catholic Midwestern parents (Tom Wilkinson and Linda Emond) and siblings to reject longstanding family traditions on marriage and sexuality. The story resolves only when the family fully accommodates the relationship, ending with both parents escorting Jenny down the aisle and a final image of the couple with their adopted child.

This structure makes the ideological reframing of traditional values the central engine of the plot rather than an incidental element. The director explicitly drew the script from her real-life niece's coming-out experience and timed the release to exploit the post-Obergefell cultural shift, presenting Catholic family norms as outdated bigotry that must be discarded for progress. Such framing turns the film into a vehicle for advancing a specific social agenda, sidelining entertainment value in favor of didactic messaging that demands audience alignment with the protagonists' perspective. Casting choices reinforce this focus by centering the same-sex relationship as the sole source of dramatic tension, leaving little room for organic character development outside the ideological conflict.